It might be harsh on champions France and Triple Crown winners
Ireland, but this season's RBS 6 Nations tournament will not linger
long in the memory.
Bizarrely, it will probably be remembered for the fluctuating fortunes of those countries that finished third to sixth.
Scotland
were transformed under new coach Frank Hadden, achieving their highest
Six Nations finish, while Italy made giant strides and at last look
comfortable in European rugby's blue riband event.
World
champions England though, sunk without trace after winning their first
two games, slumping to fourth place for a second successive campaign,
while last season's Grand Slam winners Wales struggled on the pitch and
were a shambles off it following Mike Ruddock's shock departure as
coach.
Here, PA Sport Rugby Union Correspondent Andrew Baldock
gives his end-of-term report on a tournament that had its moments, but
ultimately left little impression.
FRANCE
Coach Bernard
Laporte has achieved a fairly impressive feat in masterminding a Six
Nations title triumph, but revealing little to his main rivals ahead of
the 2007 World Cup.
France prevailed despite being without the
services of their best player - injured centre Yannick Jauzion - yet
they hardly moved out of second gear, playing only in patches against
Italy and Wales, crushing England largely through the world champions'
incompetence and rattling up 40 points against Ireland after profiting
lavishly from their opponents' mistakes.
Laporte turned to
thirtysomethings Raphael Ibanez and Olivier Magne following an opening
weekend defeat against Scotland, and their experience - combined with
Thomas Castaignede's dashing flair at full-back - helped them recover.
IRELAND
Undoubtedly
possessed the tournament's best back division, with players like Gordon
D'Arcy, Andrew Trimble and especially wing Shane Horgan all having
their moments, and a second Triple Crown in three seasons was a fair
reward for Irish endeavour.
Coach Eddie O'Sullivan also unearthed
a livewire hooker in Jerry Flannery, while line-out colossus Paul
O'Connell reigned supreme and the back-row combination of Simon
Easterby, David Wallace and Denis Leamy was perhaps the tournament's
most efficient breakaway unit.
The real test is looming for Ireland though, with two away Test matches against New Zealand awaiting them this summer.
SCOTLAND
Coach
Frank Hadden deserves every accolade in the book for transforming
Scotland's spirit and standing in European rugby following the
miserable reign of his predecessor, Australian Matt Williams.
Hadden
instilled a pride and a purpose in everything Scotland did, beginning
with a stunning victory over France, continuing by ripping the Calcutta
Cup from England's grasp and then beating Italy in Rome. Had lock Scott
Murray not been harshly sent off during a 28-18 loss to Wales, then it
is conceivable the Scots might have won four games out of five.
Captain
Jason White and his fellow back-row stars Ally Hogg and Simon Taylor
proved consistently impressive contributors, while Chris Paterson's
nerveless goalkicking also played a critical role in an outstanding
Scottish revival.
ENGLAND
World champions? World chumps
more like, on the evidence of another miserable Six Nations campaign
that saw England lose three successive games for the second season
running and finish a wholly unacceptable fourth.
They started
competently enough by brushing aside Wales and eventually winning well
in Italy, but the wheels came off against Scotland before France
punished the most shambolic English performance for years by inflicting
a 31-6 Paris drubbing on Andy Robinson's men.
England then
delivered an improved display against Ireland, but still lost, and it
is time for Robinson to seriously look at young talent such as Mathew
Tait, Tom Varndell, Tom Rees and Magnus Lund. This summer's Australia
tour should be the starting point.
WALES
Last season's
Grand Slam champions flirted with the wooden spoon, as their only Six
Nations points arrived from a win against 14-man Scotland and a home
draw that meant Italy's long run of away defeats came to a halt.
Wales
were dealt a cruel hand in terms of injuries - Ryan Jones, Tom
Shanklin, Kevin Morgan, Brent Cockbain and Chris Horsman missed the
whole tournament - but their Six Nations was totally overshadowed by
coach Mike Ruddock's departure after the Scotland game in mid-February.
With
Ruddock gone - and fall-out is continuing over the reasons why -
highly-rated Australian Scott Johnson took over on a caretaker basis,
but under his stewardship, Wales managed one draw and two defeats.
Johnson now looks set to head home and join the Wallabies' coaching
staff, so chaos reigns supreme.
ITALY
Former France
scrum-half Pierre Berbizier turned Italy into genuinely tough opponents
for all their Six Nations rivals, and had certain refereeing decisions
not gone against them, they could have collected more than just one
point and another wooden spoon.
Italy possessed the tournament's
best prop in Gloucester-bound Carlos Nieto and the best overall player
in centre Mirco Bergamasco, while back-row forward Sergio Parisse
proved occasionally good, but mostly very good.
Fly-half Ramiro
Pez was the weak link, but with Italy facing home games against Wales,
Ireland and France next season, prospects look good after finally
taking their seat at European rugby's top table and not looking out of
place.
Posted at 02:38 pm by rugbysix